Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop in Seaford

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop in Seaford
4.5 / 5
39 reviews

3649 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783-2810, Seaford

Overview

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do you have lemon cakes?

They have a vanilla cake with a layer of lemon filling and vanilla buttercream on the outside.

Do you have mince pie?

They always have it on Thanksgiving, they might have it now too, but if they dont they will make one if you ask them too.

Do you have almond crumb cake?

I am not sure

Do you make linzer torte?

Yes they do

Do you prepare fondant cakes? F lavelle

Great cakes cookies and pastries, crumb cake is unbelievable. She's a great person.

Do u sell banana bread?

No

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JO
John O'Brien
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Delicious fresh bread, great desserts and fast frendly service.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
jg
jorge galvez
google
11.18.2018
5/5

My wife likes very good bread and very good coffee.We recommended these bakery .The attention it was very good.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
CP
Cecilia Portilla
google
11.13.2018
5/5

Great bakery with products made and baked on premises. Pretzels and pretzel rolls fresh and definitely something to go out of your way for! Cakes are fantastic. Nice, friendly service always!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
sK
samohT KcirtapztiF
google
08.22.2018
3/5

Very good I liked it. But there were some empty areas in the display areas. I would come here again.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
EF
E F
google
08.10.2018
2/5

Nothing like gertz used to be.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
CR
Christina Raff
google
07.20.2018
5/5

They make the absolute best tasting buttercream frosting.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
IY
Imperfect, Yes
google
07.20.2018
2/5

Good prices for the food, but there were flies all over and the employees were treated unfairly. But the bakery itself smells really good and the food seems good, but most of the people working there need to improve their passive aggressiveness

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
AL
Anthony Lamuro
google
07.18.2018
5/5

Amazing Bakery, Family atmosphere, baked goods are superb and delicious, awesome coffee too. Exceptional Service, Wonderful place!!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JC
John Cosides
google
06.22.2018
1/5

I’m not an ex/disgruntled employee. I am an honest customer and after purchasing a very tasty cake for my birthday, My wife and I thought we found our new favorite bakery. WRONG! After a quick visit to the store to plan my children’s birthday cakes. We were told that We’d receive a call from Cathy to iron out the specific details. When she called we had therapists in for our son and we missed the call Then when she did get my wife on the phone. She yell at her for not answering and she was RUDE and she was UNPROFESSIONAL. AND not only once but TWICE. because when we called back to cancel our appointment she yelled at her again and hung up on her. As a business owner she has ZERO customer service skills. I will never buy from here again and I suggest you do the same.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
MR
Margaret Rogers
google
06.16.2018
5/5

Best bakeryGreat cakes, very accommodating, love Fehn's!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
KM
Kimberly MacDonald
google
05.24.2018
5/5

Everything I have ever had is awesome! The donuts are among my favorite donuts out there.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
RM
Robert Molinas
google
05.11.2018
5/5

Best cake place in the bellmore Merrick Seaford area

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JO
John Occhiuto
google
04.17.2018
5/5

The Bakery is very clean, they serve up a nice variety of everything from fresh donuts, delicious chocolate cakes, cookies, and strudel that I consider to be one of the best I’ve ever had (try the blueberry). Friendly and warm, I recommend this bakery highly!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
MM
Marjorie M
google
04.16.2018
4/5

I ordered a birthday cake for 25 people whipped cream and strawberry filling. This is the best birthday cake I have had since I moved to long island from Brooklyn. ( 25 years ago) its not too sweet, has real whipped cream and re as l strawberries in the filling. I cant wait for another birthday!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
MS
Mary Signorile
google
03.02.2018
5/5

Best cakes and cookies. Try cake with green sprinkles and yellow cake with chocolate fudge icing. YUMMY

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
PB
Pat B
google
03.01.2018
5/5

The absolute best pretzel rolls on Long Island! My son has a peanut allergy and has limited places to get fresh baked items. We drove 45 minutes to get there. So worth the trip!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JD
John Doe
google
02.24.2018
5/5

Excellent cakes and cookies.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
LM
Louie MASSARI
google
02.06.2018
1/5

I bought a rasbery cake ring and 6 buns, they sold me day old cake! The cake was $14.99.it was a bad experience I cannot recommend this bakery as this was the 2nd time I picked day old items and was not told.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
RJ
Ronald Jackson
google
10.26.2017
5/5

excellent Irish Soda Bread and pastries

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
AS
Anthony S
google
10.04.2017
1/5

Nasty. Nasty. Owner yelled at me from her car because I was blocking her driveway at the bakery for 5 seconds. And i was getting out of her way. I was dropping off my daughter. She then parked in the toy store lot.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
MM
Michael McPhillips
google
08.04.2017
5/5

One of the best bakeries around. Great crew. The bread and the pastries are always good.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
lh
luis hernandez
google
08.03.2017
5/5

Best muffins I've had , especially the double chocolate and blueberry. Amazing.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
FK
Firdavs Khasanov
google
07.04.2017
5/5

Visited this wonderful bakery today and really enjoyed the warm atmosphere, freshly-baked aroma. Everything they have is fresh and delicious. Must visit!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
ZP
Zachary Pensa
google
06.08.2017
4/5

Very friendly staff, very helpful. Knocking off a star for management's posted policy that staff cant use thier cell phones while working? I can understand that during a rush, but when I came in there was nobody there. On top of that, the note continues to read something to the effect of "if there's an emergency, your parents can call the landline." Not 1982 anymore, even if the bakery is a tad old school looking. Seems a bit cruel and draconian to the friendly young kids working there, and I'm a teacher so, cell phone use is not something I'm always jazzed about myself. Can understand a direction like that being given and enforced during a rush season or busy day, but I think it should be re-thought even if nobody asked for my opinion. Not enough to give it 3 stars because the bread was delicious and staff was great.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
LM
Lisa Mcdowell
google
04.24.2017
1/5

The customer service is bad. I have ordered cakes before from there and they were good but talking to Cathy over the phone was the worst experience ever! Just plain rude! Will never get anything from them again!

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
BG
Bonnie Girard
google
04.10.2017
5/5

One of the best bakery’s I’ve found in Nassau County. Dortoni’s and Sweet Surrender are also my go tos for the best.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JA
J. Aguilar Taylor
google
03.24.2017
5/5

Excellent cakes

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
df
donna farrell
google
03.11.2017
5/5

Best whip cream in Long Island. Owner is very sweet.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
LS
Lisa S
google
02.18.2017
4/5

Delicious, nice selection, always fresh.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
SS
Steven S
google
02.17.2017
1/5

Awful customer service. Especially owner

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
vi
veronica ieronimo
google
01.26.2017
2/5

Difficulty handling holiday orders in an orderly fashion, customers waiting in street to get into store for pickups. Took 1/2 hour before they worked out a solution !

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JD
Julie Day
google
11.20.2016
5/5

Excellent German Bakery, I have been a customer for more than 25 years! I am also a certified food judge with KCBS. The baked goods are fantastic. They have the largest fresh bread selection in Nassau county, and there custom order cakes are great! I highly recommend this bakery.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
TR
Thomas Rafferty
google
10.03.2016
5/5

Excellent. Great buttercream frosting and cake. Higher quality goods than most bakeries.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
AG
Arlene Giese
google
08.18.2016
5/5

It was my first time there and I was very impressed. There was a large selection of pies, cakes and cookies along with a large selection of chocolate bunnies, large, very lg, and small ones.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
CS
Christine Staab
google
07.15.2016
5/5

A slice of heaven. Has all the German baked goodies I have not been able to find since all the German cupcake shops closed in queens. Cookies are simply amazing. Always hard to leave without picking out tons of stuff.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
GK
Glenn Krieger
google
05.20.2016
5/5

Though I know it is so not good for me, I can't help but enjoy their Elmo or Spongebob cookies. Fair prices, great baked goods and good service.

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
RL
Rose Lombardo
google
05.03.2016
5/5

All I can say is delicious

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
JB
Jackie Beta
google
04.23.2016
5/5

OMG..best Eclair i have ever had..

Fehn`s Cake & Cookie Shop
TS
Tanya Senicola
google
03.09.2016
3/5

Kathy is a hard working business woman who has run a bakery long before these "so called" customers have ever stepped foot into this cake and cookie shop. Her business is an excellent contribution to the community and many happy customers can attest to that.If you are disgruntled ex employees be graceful and walk away don't try to sabotage a business by your negative reviews it's horrendous as a person This is a mom and pop bakery family owned for years and your negative fake reviews are just inappropriate and you should be ashamed of yourselves.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 15167852253

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!